Tax Planning Case Study: $60,300 in Potential Savings | Pocket CPA

Home / Resources / Case study

Illustrative scenario

Tax Planning Case Study: How a Profitable Business Owner Identified $60,300 in Potential Tax Savings

A Maryland engineering firm owner, a projected $245,900 tax bill, and twelve weeks left in 2026. What changed, what it cost, and what we left out on purpose.

The short version

A married S corporation owner with about $735,000 of profit was projected to pay roughly $245,900 in combined 2026 taxes. Three changes made before December 31 brought that projection to about $185,600, a reduction of $60,300. After $32,000 of implementation costs, the estimated first year benefit is about $28,300.

The situation

A married business owner ran an established civil engineering firm in Howard County, Maryland. The firm had grown steadily for years. The tax setup had not.

Business
Civil engineering S corporation since 2014, 7 employees
Profit before owner salary
About $735,000 on $1.9 million revenue
Household
Married filing jointly; spouse earns about $129,500
Owner
Age 54, licensed engineer, full time in the business
Owner salary
$85,000, unchanged since 2019
Retirement plan
Safe harbor 401(k), already at the deferral limits
Projected 2026 tax
About $245,900, federal, payroll, and Maryland
Prior CPA
Same firm for nine years; accurate returns, one meeting a year, no projections

The owner came in during early October 2026 with one question: "We pay more every year, and nobody can tell me if that's just the cost of doing well."

The problem

Nothing was wrong with the returns. Preparing the 2026 return well still would not have changed the 2026 tax, because the issues were all upstream of it:

  • Profit had nearly doubled since 2019, but the salary, retirement plan, and state tax setup were the same as the year the firm made half as much.
  • No one had ever built a projection. The household learned its tax bill when the return was finished.
  • Maryland tax on the business profit was paid personally, where the federal SALT cap made almost all of it nondeductible.
  • Estimated payments were set at 100% of last year's tax. Above $150,000 of AGI, the safe harbor is 110%.

What we changed

1. Maryland PTE election: about $15,800 lower federal tax

The S corporation could elect to pay Maryland income tax at the entity level and never had. With household income around $810,000, the federal SALT deduction was stuck at $10,000. An electing entity's state tax is a business deduction, so it gets around that cap. Maryland tax stays roughly the same because the owner gets a credit for what the entity pays.

What it took: make the 2026 election and pay the full entity tax (about $36,600 at Maryland's 8.75% rate) before December 31, then stop personal Maryland estimates on business income. The catch: December cash flow gets heavy, and the personal Maryland estimates already paid come back as a refund in 2027.

2. Owner salary raised to $140,000: about $11,700 higher tax

This one raised the bill, and we recommended it anyway. The owner stamps drawings, manages the staff, and brings in most of the work. Compensation data for comparable roles supported a range well above $85,000, and a salary that sat still while profit nearly doubled is exactly what draws attention in an S corporation.

The higher salary also mattered for the next step: retirement contributions are calculated on W-2 pay, so a low salary would have capped the cash balance plan. What it took: catch up payroll in the fourth quarter and write a short memo documenting the decision.

3. Cash balance plan: about $56,200 lower tax

A cash balance plan is a pension that works like an account. At 54, with steady profit and a mostly younger staff, the owner was a good fit. An actuary's preliminary illustration supported an owner contribution of about $140,000 for 2026, on top of the existing 401(k).

What it took: engaging an actuary in October, signing the plan before year end, and depositing the contribution by September 15, 2027. The catch: staff contributions rise by about $16,000 a year, setup and administration run about $6,000, funding is required annually, and the plan should run for several years. Also, about $48,900 of this savings is deferral. That tax comes due when the money is withdrawn in retirement.

What we reviewed and left alone

We looked at switching to a C corporation (the owner lives on the profits, so double tax wins), hiring the children (their wages carry payroll tax in an S corporation, and the benefit was small), charitable bunching (worth $1,000 to $2,000, not worth changing habits), real estate (revisit before any office purchase), and the last three years of returns (no material errors).

We also left out about $25,000 of savings from moving a planned equipment purchase into December. The firm was buying the equipment anyway, so most of that benefit is borrowed from future years. Counting it would have made the headline bigger and the analysis less honest.

Before and after

Projected 2026 tax by type
TaxBeforeAfterChange
Federal income tax$162,100$109,300−$52,800
Payroll tax on owner wages$13,000$21,400+$8,400
Maryland and county tax$70,800$54,900−$15,900
Total$245,900$185,600−$60,300
Projected first year economics
Estimated tax reduction$60,300
Added staff retirement contributions−$16,000
Plan setup and administration−$6,000
Tax planning engagement−$10,000
Estimated net benefit, first year$28,300

Why it had to happen before December 31

Nearly all of the $60,300 depended on something done in the last twelve weeks of 2026. If this household had waited for tax season:

  • The salary would have been locked at $85,000. W-2 wages are whatever was paid during the year.
  • The cash balance plan would have shrunk. It could technically still be adopted in 2027, but the contribution would have been calculated on $85,000 of pay.
  • The PTE deduction would have moved to 2027. A cash basis business deducts the tax in the year it is paid.

Lessons for other business owners

  1. A big tax bill is not proof of overpaying. A six figure liability does make modeling the alternatives worth the time.
  2. The big numbers came from elections and plan design, not from finding forgotten receipts.
  3. Some correct advice costs money. The salary change raised the bill and made everything else defensible.
  4. Strategies interact. The retirement plan shrank the PTE tax, and the salary changed both. Modeling them one at a time gives the wrong answer.

"The objective is not to chase every strategy available. It is to find the handful that actually fit the client's income, business, cash flow, risk tolerance, and timeline. One of the more useful things in this plan was raising someone's salary, which is not what people expect from a tax planner. I would rather show a client a smaller number they can trust than a bigger one that falls apart at the second question."

Manny Sandhu, CPA, Managing Partner

Wondering what your own projection would show?

If your business is generating $400,000 or more in profit, or you are paying approximately $100,000 or more annually in combined taxes, Pocket CPA can evaluate whether proactive planning opportunities may exist in your situation.

Contact Pocket CPA

If the numbers do not justify ongoing planning, we will tell you that too.

Assumptions and fine print
  1. 2026 federal brackets, QBI thresholds, and retirement limits per IRS Revenue Procedure 2025-32 and the IRS 2026 cost of living adjustments. Married filing jointly, Howard County residents.
  2. S corporation profit of $735,000 before owner salary, owner payroll taxes, and owner retirement contributions. Staff W-2 wages of $610,000. Engineering treated as outside the specified service category for QBI.
  3. Itemized deductions: $11,500 property tax (SALT capped at $10,000), $16,000 mortgage interest, $20,000 cash gifts subject to the 0.5% AGI floor. Spouse's W-2 includes a $24,500 pretax deferral; owner defers $24,500 plus an $8,000 pretax catch up.
  4. Projected tax includes federal income tax, NIIT, and additional Medicare tax; payroll taxes on owner wages (both halves); and Maryland state and 3.20% Howard County tax, including PTE tax at 8.75% with a resident credit. Spouse's payroll taxes are unchanged and excluded.
  5. Cash balance contribution from a hypothetical preliminary actuarial illustration. Changes measured in the order listed. Amounts rounded to the nearest $100.

For a full explanation of each strategy, who it fits, and the 2026 deadlines, see How Can Business Owners Making $500K+ Reduce Their Tax Bill?

This case study is an illustrative composite for educational purposes. It is not tax, legal, or investment advice. Projected savings depend on facts, assumptions, and proper implementation, and actual results will differ.